Projects Funded for Diane Charlton

2020-2021

The Impacts of COVID-19 on the Farm Labor Supply and Farming Decisions in California

J. Edward Taylor, Zachariah Rutledge, Bryan Little, and Diane Charlton

Abstract

Specific Objectives of the Project:

  1. To analyze the extent to which the COVID-19 health crisis affected California farmers’ access to farm workers in 2020.
  2. To analyze how COVID-19 affected farming decisions in California in 2020.
  3. To analyze how the COVID-19 pandemic is likely to influence the use of labor-saving technologies in the future.

Summary of Results:
We surveyed a broad sample of fruit, vegetable, horticultural, and nursery farmers covering California and the entire United States, in conjunction with the California Farm Bureau Federation, the National Council of Agricultural Employers, and American Hort. Surveyed farmers reported significant labor shortages. For example, in a national survey, nearly two-thirds of the farmers reported having difficulty hiring all the workers they wanted to produce their main commodity in their highest revenue producing state during 2021. The average farmer who would have normally hired 100 workers but faced a labor shortage would have only been able to hire 82 during 2021.

Farmers reported incurring additional costs related to COVID-19, including purchasing additional personal protective equipment, extra cleaning and sanitation activities, and adding sanitation facilities for workers. Some farmers reported spending thousands of dollars on each employee. COVID-19 played a role in the labor shortage issues that California farmers reported, with over half of the farmers who experienced a shortage indicating that COVID exacerbated it. Farmers reported a number of factors related to COVID-19 that contributed to labor shortages, including direct exposure to the virus, shelter-in-place orders, and generous unemployment benefits that allowed workers to obtain more income by not working. Most farmers who faced labor shortages indicated that the labor shortages were worse in 2020 than 2019.

H-2A workers are increasingly common, consistent with a USDA Economic Research Service study (co-authored by Professor Rutledge) revealing that H-2A visa use is rapidly expanding (Castillo, Martin, and Rutledge, 2022). There is no sign of this trend slowing down. H-2A workers continued to constitute a small share of labor use among California survey respondents. However, the H-2A program in California is expanding rapidly (Martin and Rutledge, 2022).

A significant share of farmers reported using a new labor-saving technology to help them mitigate problems stemming from labor scarcity. More than a third nation-wide made changes to their product mix to reduce labor costs. One in three California farmers reported implementing new labor-saving technologies in 2020, and among these, the main labor-saving technology was used on an average of 66% of their main crop production in their main county. The most oft-cited reasons for using labor-saving technologies and mechanical harvest aids, respectively, were rising labor costs and the ability to harvest faster.

Overall, this project found that many farmers face significant issues stemming from a lack of labor, while many are struggling to navigate the situation. Farmers are clearly making efforts to mitigate production and profit losses resulting from labor shortages; however, this issue continues to be a major challenge for fruit, vegetable and horticultural and nursery farmers in California and throughout the United States.

As background for these studies, we conducted detailed reviews of the changing agricultural workforce in the US and abroad, why it is happening, and its implications (Charlton, Rutledge and Taylor 2021); the agricultural labor supply response (Hill, Ornelas and Taylor 2021); and the future of work in agri-food (Christiaensen, Rutledge and Taylor 2021).

2019-2020

The Impacts of a Declining Farm Labor Supply on Farming in California

J. Edward Taylor, Diane Charlton, and Stavros Vougioukas

Abstract

Specific Objectives of the Project: Objective

  1. To analyze how labor shortages are affecting the use of the H-2A visa program and farm labor contractors in California.
  2. To analyze how higher labor costs are affecting the crop mix, the use of labor-saving technologies, and cultivation practices in California.
  3. To analyze the extent to which reductions in the farm labor supply are affecting the production of fruit and vegetable crops in California.

Project Report/Summary of Results:
The funds provided through this grant enabled us to continue processing and analyzing the data we collected from a 2019 survey that we conducted in collaboration with the California Farm Bureau Federation. Additional analysis of these data revealed that farmers have found it increasingly difficult to gain access to an adequate supply of farm workers between 2014 and 2018. Fifty-eight percent of the 1000+ farmers we surveyed reported that they were unable to hire enough workers at some point between 2014 and 2018, and a higher share of those reporting labor shortages between that time span said that they experienced shortages in 2017 and 2018. In response to labor-availability problems, farmers reported making a variety of changes to their usual production practices. First of all, the vast majority of farmers reported having to raise wages to attract and retain workers. Between 2014 and 2018, the share of farmers reporting that they had to raise wages to attract workers increased from 31% to 79%. Second, farmers report becoming increasingly reliant upon farm labor contractors (FLC) and the H-2A visa program. The most common reason for using an FLC was to make sure they had enough workers, while about a quarter
of respondents indicated that they used them to reduce the administrative burden associated with hiring farm workers. About 5% of farmers indicated that they had switched acreage out of labor-intensive fruit and vegetable crop production into mechanically-harvested crops. Of those who indicated that they had switched some acreage out of labor-intensive crop production into non-labor-intensive crops, the majority switched into the production of tree nuts, revealing evidence that is consistent with some media reports. About one-third of the farmers indicated that they had to change one (or more) of their usual cultivation practices at some point between 2014 and 2018 either because there were not enough workers available or because of rising labor costs. The percentage of farmers who reported having to change cultivation practices increased by 18 percentage points between 2014 and 2018. Roughly twenty percent of the farmers indicated that they had started using a labor-saving technology for the first time between 2014 and 2018. The most common types of labor-saving technologies were mechanical harvesters for wine grapes and specialized tractor attachments. The main reason for adopting these technologies was rising labor costs; although, over half of those who adopted a labor-saving technology for the first time also said that farm worker availability played a role in the decision, too.

Additional research that was conducted under this grant included ongoing work with cooperating personnel member Diane Charlton, which led to a (forthcoming) publication in the journal Agricultural Economics (see publication section below). This work uses panel data from a nationally-representative survey of rural households in Mexico and finds that educational attainment among rural Mexicans, which has been stimulated by investments by the Mexican government, has led to a decline in the supply of farm workers. This decline in the supply of farm workers is driven by higher returns in non-farm sectors of the economy due to the acquisition of valuable human capital, which has opened up opportunities to engage in non-farm employment for rural Mexicans.

2018-2019

The Impacts of a Declining Farm Labor Supply on Farming in California

J. Edward Taylor, Zachariah Rutledge, and Diane Charlton

Abstract

Specific Objectives of the Project: Objective
1: To estimate recent and future trends in California farm wages.
2: To analyze the farm labor supply response to changes in farm wages.
3: To explore how increases in California farm wages affect the adoption of labor-saving technologies, the mix of labor-intensive crop production, and the employment of H-2A visa workers.

Project Report/Summary of Results
The funds provided through this grant enabled us to develop and implement an online survey of California farmers to study how they are adapting to the reduced availability of farmworkers. This survey was developed with the cooperation of the California Farm Bureau Federation (Sara Neagu-Reed and Bryan Little), who helped develop the survey and sent it to their members and affiliated grower groups on our behalf. The survey was tailored to elicit information related to (i) the extent to which farmers have had to increase wages to retain an adequate workforce, (ii) the use of farm labor contractors and the H-2A visa program, (iii) changes in acreage resulting from higher wages or reduced access to farmworkers, (iv) the adoption of labor-saving technologies, and (v) changes in cultivation practices resulting from labor scarcity. Over 1000 farmers responded to the survey. Some key findings from the survey include evidence that (i) the rate at which farmers have to pay higher wages to retain a sufficient workforce is increasing, (ii) the use of farm labor contractors and the H-2A visa program is expanding, (iii) some farmers are reducing acreage dedicated to labor-intensive crops and are switching into less labor-intensive crops like nuts and grain/row crops, (iv) many farmers (about 1/3 in our survey) have started using labor-saving technologies for the first time during the past few years, and (v) farmers are increasingly having to change cultivation practices as a result of reduced access to workers, including reducing or delaying pruning, weeding, and harvesting. Additional work will quantify the effects of labor shortages and higher wages on these various outcomes, but the survey format was tailored to facilitate these types of analyses and provide the data to conduct them.

We also engaged in a collaborative effort to co-author two Choices Magazine articles, one of which has been accepted for publication (the other is currently under review). The first article conveys the economic theory behind a farmer’s decision to adopt a labor-saving technology in the face of higher wages and includes a discussion about agricultural technologies that have been used and are being developed to help farmers produce with a smaller workforce. The second article discusses trends in farmworker employment and wages and draws upon previous research supported by the Giannini Foundation to provide estimates of how high farm wages will need to increase in order to keep the farm workforce stable.
Taylor and Charlton’s new book, The Farm Labor Problem: A Global Perspective, was published by Elsevier Academic Press in December 2018, with acknowledgement to support from the Giannini Foundation of Agricultural Economics. We created a website to feature the book and other farm labor research; see https://farmlabor.ucdavis.edu/.

There is substantial interest in this area of research, as can be seen by recent invitations for us to present work related to this topic at conferences, including the UC Davis Agriculture and Natural Resource Annual Vegetable Crops meeting, the World Bank’s Future of Work in Agriculture conference, the Department of Labor’s NAWS at 30 conference, and the Gifford Center for Population Studies’ Farm Labor 2019 conference.